SAMPLE REVIEW FORM
 
Briefly summarize the paper in your own words, making sure to identify the paper's contribution to the field of education and/or educational technology.
How RELEVANT is this paper?
Very relevant
Moderately relevant
Not relevant

Please explain your rating?
How SIGNIFICANT is this paper?
Very significant
Moderately significant
Not significant

Please explain your rating?
How ORIGINAL is this paper?
Very original
Moderately original
Not original

Please explain your rating?
Please comment on the QUALITY of this paper?


Please comment on the CLARITY of this paper?


Please comment on the appropriateness of the title, abstract and conclusion?


Detailed Feedback for Authors




Overall Summary

My overall recommendation is
Definitely accept
Minor revisions required before accept
Major revisions required before accept
Definitely reject
Recommended minor revisions? (if any)


Recommended major revisions? (if any)


How confident are you in your appropriateness as a referee for this paper?
Very confident - I am an expert in this area.
Confident - I have a reasonable knowledge of this area.
Fairly confident - I have some knowledge of this area.
Not confident - I have no significant knowledge of this area.
If this paper is marginal or unusual in some way, can you comment on anything else that might help the editors reach a decision?


If you want to upload the manuscript annotated with your comments please use the button below: